Scotland: the painful divorce?

David Cameron said yesterday: “It is my duty to be clear about the likely consequences of a Yes vote. Independence would not be a trial separation. It would be a painful divorce.”

In his analogy, Scotland is one side of a partnership; the rest of the UK makes up the other side. A Yes vote for independence would amount to Scotland walking away from the relationship, divorcing the rest of the UK in a permanent separation.

Yet the divorce analogy is also directly applicable to the ongoing campaign. Yes and No closely resemble a divorcing couple, with Scotland caught in the middle of a messy series of arguments.

scotland on the fence

And, like the parents who insist however badly they act towards each other it is for the sake of the children, Yes and No seem prepared to wield any available weapon because they have Scotland’s best interests at heart.

Alex Salmond has tainted the Yes campaign by trying to paint everything he thinks voters don’t like with a Tory brush, and he spent much of Monday talking about BBC bias rather than pro-Scottish issues. On Sunday’s Andrew Marr show, Alistair Darling once again chose to emphasize the risks of voting for independence and the permanency of the decision, saying there would be “no way back”. (If your campaign is called Better Together, isn’t it a good idea to focus on the benefits of staying in the UK rather than on the drawbacks of choosing independence? I really think they should have renamed it Worse Apart. )

But to return to the analogy as Cameron used it, today we see the alternative to “the painful divorce”, as the front page of the Daily Record carries in full “the vow”. David Cameron, Ed Miliband and Nick Clegg are seeking to counteract the threat of divorce with a renewal of vows to strengthen the marriage. Will it be enough to rekindle the spark in the relationship?

The problem is that if the No vote (which I continue to see as the most likely outcome) wins by a narrow margin, it will still show significant dissatisfaction with the status quo. Once the spectre of the end of a relationship has been raised, it’s difficult to continue to feel truly in love, unless there is a dramatic rejection of the outside threat.

Divorce would certainly be the most painful option economically. But it could be emotionally messier if 49.9% declare themselves out of the relationship and wake up on the morning of 19th September to find they are still married.


2 thoughts on “Scotland: the painful divorce?

  1. At first I marvelled at how comprehensively English politicians made voting “No” seem like something that no self respecting Scot would want to do. Now, I just think that they have missed the point. If I were eligible to vote, I’d still be struggling with an overwhelming desire to vote “Yes” but I hope I’d manage to hold on to the idea that “No” is better. I’ve been noticing the intolerance and shaky promises and tendency to blame everything on Westminster- and it would make me very uneasy to embrace something like that.


  2. It’s difficult, isn’t it? Before watching the televised debates, I had seen No as the default position, but even though I *know* Salmond can’t be trusted he spoke very well about personal and constitutional freedom, “this is our moment” etc., and Yes suddenly seemed the more attractive option.

    I personally hope Scotland vote to stay. Being Northern Irish, it sort of ties the UK together having Scotland there, as there’s a lot of cultural overlap (especially between north-east NI and Western Scotland, which have a bit of a Belfast-Liverpool type connection). But it’s definitely a matter for the Scottish people to decide, and I don’t really envy them this one. I just hope that, whatever happens, Scotland continues to thrive; it’s a great country.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s